Vanguard or BetaShares for your diversified ETF?
Late last year, BetaShares entered the diversified exchange traded fund (ETF) space, joining Vanguard who were the only providers in Australia at the time.
Both had four funds in high growth (90% growth/10% defensive), growth (70%/30%), balanced (50%/50%) and conservative categories (25%/75% for BetaShares; 30%/70% for Vanguard).
Vanguard had a management fee of 0.27% for its diversified ETFs; while BetaShares currently offered a slightly lower rate of 0.26%, which would be adjusted to 0.39% for all four funds except for the high growth fund, which would be lowered to 0.19% on 15 December, 2020.
According to FE Analytics, since the start of the year to 31 October, 2020, Vanguard’s Diversified Conservative Index ETF had the best return, with 1.65%.
This was in contrast to BetaShares’ counterpart which lost 2.31% since the start of the year.
Vanguard’s Diversified Balanced ETF returned 0.06% while BetaShares’ counterpart lost 0.35%.
When it came to diversified growth, Vanguard lost 1.57%, while BetaShares lost 2.31%.
And finally, for diversified high growth, Vanguard lost 3.68%, while BetaShares lost 4.15%.
Both firm’s products where relatively new to the market, as Vanguard launched its line-up on 20 November, 2017.
Since inception to 31 October, 2020, Diversified High Growth returned 17.5%, Diversified Growth returned 17.32%, Diversified Balanced returned 16.36% and Conservative returned 15%.
BetaShares launched its four diversified products last year with Diversified High Growth first on 3 December and Diversified Conservative Income last on 10 December.
BetaShares’ diversified funds were comprised of other ETFs that invested in specific asset classes, while Vanguard’s invested in its own wholesale funds.
All four Vanguard funds included the same underlying funds: Australian Shares Index, International Shares, International Shares Index (Hedged), International Small Companies Index, Emerging Markets Shares Index, Global Aggregate Bond Index (Hedged), and Australian Fixed Interest Index.
However, the conservative strategy also provided an allocation to Vanguard’s Cash Reserve fund.
Performance of BetaShares and Vanguard diversified ETFs since the start of 2020 to 30 October 2020
AUTHOR
Chris Dastoor
Recommended for you
Natixis Investment Managers has hired a distribution director to specifically focus on the firm’s work with research firms and consultants.
The use of total portfolio approaches by asset allocators is putting pressure on fund managers with outperformance being “no longer sufficient” when it comes to fund development.
With evergreen funds being used by financial advisers for their liquidity benefits, Harbourvest is forecasting they are set to grow by around 20 per cent a year to surpass US$1 trillion by 2029.
Total monthly ETF inflows declined by 28 per cent from highs in November with Vanguard’s $21bn Australian Shares ETF faring worst in outflows.
