Planners ditch stock-picking
Financial planners are ditching direct equities for managed funds, according to Zenith head of sales and marketing John Nicoll.
Nicoll said he had seen a clear shift away from direct equities and back to managed funds over the past year due to planners' inability to keep track of performance - and resulting poor returns.
"If you ask an adviser whether they can show you their true performance compared to benchmarks, it's very, very rare that they can actually track the true performance that they're delivering," he said.
Benchmark performance reflected the average and was not indicative of the best asset managers, according to Nicoll. As a result it acted as a poor comparative measure.
Many planners' performance could not be compared to the best equities managers who had a horde of staff who were focused on that core task, he said.
There was no evidence that tactical asset allocation had been more successful than traditional strategic asset allocation, according to Nicoll. He said the amount of time tactical allocation took could be counter-productive, even in the case of good performance.
"We've rarely seen evidence of somebody who's a true tactical allocator who comes out with a greater result than somebody who is a traditional strategic asset allocator (who) maintains a long-term view and traditional long-term allocations," he said.
He said a planner's client base would determine their use of direct equities and strategy. Some were very good at it, but for the majority of smaller planner groups with mum and dad clients, model portfolios could add more value for the client, Nicoll said.
Recommended for you
Infrastructure assets are well-positioned to hedge against global uncertainty and can enhance the diversification of traditional portfolios with their evergreen characteristics, an investment chief believes.
Volatility in US markets means currency is becoming a critical decision factor in Australian investors’ ETF selection this year.
Clime Investment Management is overhauling the selection process for its APLs, with managing director Michael Baragwanath describing the threat of a product failure affecting clients as “pure nightmare fuel”.
Global X will expand its ETF range of exchange-traded funds next month with a low-cost Australian equity product as it chases ambitions of becoming a top issuer of ETFs in Australia.
