Moves to curtail hedging opposed
Moves by the Federal Government to impose laws that curtail brokers' use of client funds to hedge against financial risk have met with opposition by a lobby group.
The newly formed CFD and Margin FX Association, which is an alliance of domestic and international derivatives providers, said the Government's move to ban hedging as part of reforms to the Corporations Act would severely damage investors and financial trading firms.
It further argued that the Government was adopting a regulatory regime that was similar to the UK, which left mum and dad investors worse off when a major trading firm crumbled.
The reforms come in the wake of collapses of two major global financial trading houses, MF Global and BBY.
Director of the lobby group, Matt Murphie, argued the Government should compare the effectiveness of client protection in the UK and Australia.
"In the UK, MF Global operated under the unhedged model, while the Australian firm used the hedged model," Murphie said.
"In the UK, the distribution payment to clients was short 10 cents in the dollar, while in Australia the distribution was short only 1 cent. Investors in Australia were clearly better off here so why are we using this collapse as a reason to move to UK regulation?
He argued that the reforms would give mum and dad investors a false sense of security that they have boosted protection, and said the changes favour a few large multinational companies that run large amounts of risk, and see reforms as a way of reducing competition.
Murphie also urged the Government to consult the industry before implementing the forms.
"While the Treasury's draft policy makes good progress in better protection of client money, eliminating hedging may inadvertently increase financial risk in the sector and leave customer's vulnerable to losing money," Murphie said.
Recommended for you
Platinum Asset Management has put its two closed-end funds under strategic review in a bid to reduce the share price discount to pre-tax NTA and maximise shareholder value.
In the latest Meet the Manager profile, Money Management speaks with Michael Skinner, founder and managing director at Blackwattle Investment Partners.
Perpetual has seen AUM rise 6 per cent in the last quarter but the departure of a longstanding JOHCM fund manager led to outflows of $2.2 billion from his strategy.
Global fixed income fund Bentham Global Opportunities has been added to several major platforms, enabling it to be accessed more easily by financial advisers.