This urge to merge is anti-competitive says Paul Cahill
The current scramble to create scale among superannuation funds is anti-competitive, according to Club Plus chief executive Paul Cahill.
He said 'mergers' involving a larger and smaller fund were often takeovers disguised as mergers, where the dominant fund wiped out the weaker one.
"This urge to merge is actually anti-competitive," Cahill said.
Super fund mergers rarely fit perfectly and he questioned what the point was if the members were not better off, according to Cahill.
He said some of the recent fund mergers were illogical and pursued simply to create scale.
"Some of the mergers we've been seeing lately - I bet the board are sitting there going 'what have we done?'" Cahill said.
He said superannuation funds needed to approach mergers scientifically to marry up products and services, but it was not in members' best interests to dilute the fund's value proposition, which had run-on affects to community and engagement.
While most small funds had been approached by a larger one to discuss the possibility of merging, Cahill said, Club Plus with its 105,000 membership base had not had any discussions at all.
"Most funds have had coffee and a chat - we haven't had anything," he said.
Cahill said larger funds did not have anything to offer Club Plus, which was already a low-cost fund with its own services and ample investment options.
The fund wants to stay independent, with Cahill saying the only reason they would merge would be because of events outside of their control.
"Those sorts of things which are totally uncontrollable by us, and they're the things in the end [that] will determine whether or not we can remain independent … if it gets to the point where the Government says no, our state of policy is to have 30 funds, then I doubt we'll be an independent fund," he said.
Recommended for you
Two commentators have shared why cultural alignment can be the biggest deal breaker when it comes to advice M&A and how to ensure a successful fit.
With an abundance of private market options coming to market, due diligence becomes increasingly important as advisers separate the wheat from the chaff, adviser Charlie Viola has said.
The Treasury has launched a consultation into how the $47 million special levy for the Compensation Scheme of Last Resort will be funded.
With the final tally for FY25 now confirmed, how many advisers left during the financial year and how does it compare to the previous year?
