Planners shifting away from benchmark hugging managers



Financial planners have moved away from mainstream broad cap managers who have clustered around the benchmark and are opting to use specialist managers to generate returns and income according to Hyperion Asset Management managing director Tim Samway.
According to Samway there has been a shift in planner thinking since the introduction of the Future of Financial Advice (FOFA) reforms where planners are becoming more critical of the cost of investments compared to the returns they are generating.
He said planners are no longer using high alpha managers who tend to cluster around benchmarks but are instead looking at exchange traded funds (ETF) or direct equities combined with specialist funds from smaller managers.
"Planners are becoming worried when they see broad cap managers all on the same side of the market and are moving away from them and looking at funds that can offer differentiated investments," Samway said.
"I have heard this repeated in dozens of meetings with boutique and large scale practices, including those aligned with institutions."
Samway said that since FOFA planners have developed a greater inbuilt attitude around the interests of clients and have moved away from inhouse products.
He said planners were looking at products which demonstrated they had thought about the client's needs and interests and were examining how funds blend and how they are protecting investment capital.
"Managers have taken the safety route and planners want quality assets that provide growth which is why they are looking at vanilla investments such as ETFs combined with specialist active managers."
Recommended for you
WT Financial has announced its second “Hubco” with a combined valuation of $7.8 million, while its first one has successfully incorporated and is now making its own acquisitions.
Remediation and litigation costs have led AMP to announce a reduced statutory net profit after tax of $98 million for the first half of 2025.
Stakeholders in the professional year discussion underscore the challenges in the current pipeline and what is holding back licensees from taking on new candidates.
Colonial First State has partnered with JP Morgan Asset Management to make its inaugural private equity allocation, continuing the firm’s expansion into unlisted asset classes.