No case for independent directors on industry funds

11 August 2014
| By Malavika |
image
image
expand image

There is no proof that mandating independent directors on not-for-profit superannuation funds would enhance fund performance, a report reveals.

Centre-left think tank the McKell Institute published a report based on 25 years of data, which showed the representative trustee governance structure is more likely to boost retirement incomes.

Titled ‘The Success of Representative Governance on Superannuation Boards', the report showed super funds governed by a board that had representatives from employer and employee bodies have outdone for-profit appointed trustee competitors on super performance criteria.

"After trawling extensively through 25 years' worth of rich statistical evidence, empirical data, and existing research the report ends up asking one very worthy question: when a system is working better than the alternative, why tamper with it?" the Institute's executive director Sam Crosby asked.

"If the goal is maximising retirement savings for Australians then the model most closely aligned to satisfying it is the one used by industry super funds."

He added the Abbott Government should wait before it mandates reform in the area without giving proof that change will be beneficial.

Industry Super Australia chair Peter Collins said: "The fact is we should not be surprised that the representative governance model has worked well for Australian retirees.

"Industry super funds have provided an excellent example of how employer and employee representatives can work cooperatively to deliver for Australians.

Read more about:

AUTHOR

 

Recommended for you

 

MARKET INSIGHTS

sub-bg sidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

Squeaky'21

My view is that after 2026 there will be quite a bit less than 10,000 'advisers' (investment advisers) and less than 100...

1 week ago
Jason Warlond

Dugald makes a great point that not everyone's definition of green is the same and gives a good example. Funds have bee...

1 week ago
Jasmin Jakupovic

How did they get the AFSL in the first place? Given the green light by ASIC. This is terrible example of ASIC's incompet...

1 week 1 day ago

AustralianSuper and Australian Retirement Trust have posted the financial results for the 2022–23 financial year for their combined 5.3 million members....

9 months 1 week ago

A $34 billion fund has come out on top with a 13.3 per cent return in the last 12 months, beating out mega funds like Australian Retirement Trust and Aware Super. ...

9 months ago

The verdict in the class action case against AMP Financial Planning has been delivered in the Federal Court by Justice Moshinsky....

9 months 2 weeks ago

TOP PERFORMING FUNDS

ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND