Planners still struggling with ethics
Some Australian financial advisers are still struggling to come to terms with their ethical obligations, according to new research undertaken at Victoria University.
The research, undertaken by Dr June Smith as part of her PhD thesis, points to the number of consumer complaints around perceived unethical conduct on the part of advisers associated with misleading statements about the performance, features and risks of recommending financial products and the business reputations of those associated with the products.
According to Smith’s analysis, the research findings raise questions about the “commoditised approach” to financial advice used by some financial advisers and “the ongoing failure to accurately match financial products to the needs, circumstances and objectives of clients”.
She said the data suggested that financial advisers “still struggle with even basic legal concepts such as having a ‘reasonable basis’ for advice and ensuring ‘suitability’ of the advice to the client”.
The analysis said that this was usually compounded by a failure to appropriately apply tolerance to risk assessments.
Looking at the complaints analysis, Smith said it highlighted a pattern of overreliance on template Statements of Advice not tailored to a client’s specific circumstances.
“The widespread use of substantial templating of advice poses ethical risks of its own and can at times lead to greater risk to consumers,” she said. “It also hinders the adviser’s ability to fully disclose all matters relevant to an informed decision-making process.”
The research analysis went on to suggest that individual competency levels amongst financial advisers were currently too low to allow them to resolve the complex ethical dilemmas they face in their daily practice.
AUTHOR
Mike Taylor
Recommended for you
The profession is up by almost 200 advisers for the new financial year, with August continuing the consistent weekly positive gains.
WT Financial has announced its second “Hubco” with a combined valuation of $7.8 million, while its first one has successfully incorporated and is now making its own acquisitions.
The Australian Wealth Advisors Group has entered into a joint venture with a Melbourne financial services firm to launch a wealth manager.
Remediation and litigation costs have led AMP to announce a reduced statutory net profit after tax of $98 million for the first half of 2025.
