NAB insists fees for no service a “process issue”
The National Australia Bank (NAB) chief executive, Andrew Thorburn, has defended some fees for no service charged by the bank as a “process issue” rather than dishonesty, as he came under fire from Counsel assisting the Commission, Michael Hodge SC, at the Royal Commission today.
“Dishonesty goes to intent and I don’t think I’ve seen this case and others where there was an intention to not do the right thing … I think it was wrong that we didn’t pick it up, and I think that we got onto it reasonably quickly,” Thorburn said, when drilled by Hodge on the bank’s former practice of retaining fees when clients were transferred to MLC.
He admitted that NAB did not have the right checks and balances in place, but said that the bulk transfers that occurred were “quite manual” and done without that intent.
“It wasn’t 'let’s do it and see if we can get away with it' … it wasn’t that at all, it was a process issue,” he said, adding that when a complaint was made they acted “reasonable quickly” on it.
Thorburn also faced questioning on the commissions paid by the bank, with Hodge suggesting that commissions made to advisers sending clients to the bank for loans or other services were paid first and foremost in the clients’ interests.
“It seems like the main benefit to you rather than the customer, that is what you obtain is having one of these professionals effectively offer either explicitly or implicitly their endorsement to the customer of going to NAB,” the senior counsel said.
Thorburn disagreed: “It’s really just an opening of a door … it’s like anybody, one person recommending something to someone else. So I really do believe it’s a benefit for the customer, for convenience and speed and confidence, in seeing somebody who is endorsed by somebody who they respect.”
When asked why NAB would need to pay advisers if the recommendation was done in line with their professional duties, Thorburn said that while they often were not paid, he believed that in some cases it was justified.
“When you have a business where the nature of what they do is financial matters, and we have said that it’s important that that’s incidental or supplementary to their business, we still think it’s a legitimate commercial transaction to pay the referrer,” he said.
“Now, you’re pushing into some risk in this and I agree … but I think we’ve really constrained it for the moment and we’ve got some better controls happening.”
Hodge also asked the CEO whether NAB’s announcement that it would let 6,000 employees go last year would come at a cost to compliance and remediation, to which Thorburn insisted it should now as compliance was already getting more investment than it had before.
AUTHOR
Hannah Wootton
Recommended for you
Ahead of the 1 January 2026 education deadline for advisers, ASIC has issued its ‘final warning’ to the industry, reporting that more than 2,300 relevant providers could be on their way out.
As high-net-worth investors look to opportunities in alternatives, Praemium has revealed that advisers who can deliver on this demand tend to have deeper relationships with their clients as they are seeking more involvement in the investment process.
As adviser-client relationships stabilise, Investment Trends’ latest report said digital hybrid advice models are key to addressing the supply-demand gap in Australia.
A Koda Capital partner and executive team member, who joined the firm from almost a decade in advice roles at AMP, has departed the wealth manager.
