MIS model 'commercially unsustainable': NSW Farmers' Association
The managed investment scheme (MIS) model has proven to be “commercially unsustainable”, according to the New South Wales Farmers’ Association.
The association’s view is contained in its submission to the parliamentary inquiry into MIS's. The association believes that the decision to invest in a MIS is based on the “tax deductibility of the investment rather than any interest in the entity’s long-term profitability”. Furthermore, the submission states that the MIS remunerative system “ensures only a small proportion of investor funding makes it as capital for the business operation”. This significantly impedes the longer-term viability of the operation.
“No commercially focused business can afford to pay the substantial commissions and fees MIS’s reportedly paid and expect to remain both competitive and financially viable,” the association’s submission states.
The Product Disclosure Statements issued within the agribusiness MIS sector are also “very general or delivered in a style that demanded interpretation” from advisers who, “in many instances, were offered significant commissions from the sale of MIS products”.
The association’s submission pointed to the fact that every other OECD country has rejected MIS's. The recent slowdown in inflows into MIS’s in Australia is also “indicative of the perception that MIS's are not sound investment decisions”.
Recommended for you
Multiple industry organisations have shared their thoughts on AFCA’s proposed rules amendment, supporting the idea of firms being named publicly when they fail to comply with determinations.
Channel Capital has appointed a head of investment oversight who joins from 14 years at asset consulting firm JANA Investment Advisers.
Licensee Centrepoint Alliance has completed the acquisition of Brighter Super’s annual review service advice book, via Financial Advice Matters.
ASIC has launched court proceedings against the responsible entity of three managed investment schemes with around 600 retail investors.
