ASIC’s Medcraft misguided on national exam
Calls by Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) chairman, Greg Medcraft, for a national adviser exam have been challenged by the Capital Markets Cooperative Research Centre (CMCRC) as likely to have little real impact and as being likely to generate a false sense of security.
CMCRC chief executive, Professor Michael Aitken said that while Medcraft's call was likely to be well-intentioned there was little evidence to suggest that an exam would increase trust and confidence in financial advice.
Further, he argued that ASIC had not yet fulfilled its own responsibilities with respect to defining appropriate operational measures.
Aitken suggested that a better approach would be to first determine whether introducing such an exam would make a positive difference and lead to positive outcomes.
"Personally I doubt whether the ability to pass an exam is going to have any impact on integrity-challenged individuals other than clearly telling them where the line they are not to cross actually is," he said. "I rather think such individuals are likely to ace such tests and provide investors with a false sense of security."
Aitken linked the proposal for the exam to the wider issue of regulators' inability to formulate clearly how the changes they regularly authorise to markets meet their mandate.
"ASIC has been making or authorising changes to the structure of financial markets for years without ever providing a procedure, let alone systematic evidence, on how those changes affect its objective of ensuring financial markets are ‘fair and efficient'. It boils down to accountability," he said
Aitken proposed that, as guardians of the markets' integrity and efficiency, ASIC needed to measure both fairness and efficiency, having first defined the terms ‘fair' and ‘efficient' and sought operational measures of each.
Recommended for you
Over half of wealth management clients in Asia-Pacific say they are looking for more advice in investment and financial planning services, according to EY, and may switch or add new providers to achieve this.
As artificial intelligence continues to reshape how the advice industry operates, Adviser Ratings unpacks which areas advisers are using the technology to improve the client experience.
Insignia Financial has appointed the former APAC head of a global asset manager to its board.
Financial advisers have been warned against advising clients to withdraw superannuation for medical or dental treatments as a new report highlights the long-term effect on balances at retirement.