Government confirms outcome of second YFYS consultation

your future your super Stephen Jones performance test

20 June 2023
| By Laura Dew |
expand image

Minister for Financial Services, Stephen Jones, has announced changes to the Your Future, Your Super (YFYS) model to ensure all trustees are held to account for fund performance.

Earlier this year, the government announced the findings from a stakeholder consultation on YFYS and launched a second consultation on the proposed changes that it said would be explored before the August 2023 performance test.

Common complaints from stakeholders about the test had included that it could unintentionally affect investment decisions to reduce the risk of failure by encouraging short-termism and benchmark hugging as well as discouraging certain investments. Values-based products are a key example of where the investment strategy may deviate from benchmarks.

Treasury had now announced what the confirmed changes were including updating the benchmarks used to measure fund performance and extending the scrutiny to Choice funds.

Jones said: “APRA’s recent Superannuation Choice Heatmap found one in five Choice investment options had significantly poor performance over eight years. Around 30 per cent of products had significantly high administration fees.

“The insights highlight that many members are at risk of poor retirement outcomes. Subjecting more superannuation products to performance testing means members can see how their fund is comparing to others. It also means members will be individually notified if their fund is underperforming.”

The minimum testing period will be progressively increased for all products from five to seven years to align with the increase in the lookback period from eight to 10 years.

The text in the notification letter sent to members in failing Choice products will be adjusted to flag cost considerations for certain members, taking into account the nature of different TDPs.

Platform products
The representative administration fees and expenses (RAFE) for platform trustee-directed products (TDPs) will be tested against the median RAFE of other platform TDPs to compare a similar level of service.

The investment performance of platform TDPs will also be tested using gross of tax variables to reflect how these products operate and report to APRA.

The RAFE of non-platform TDPs will be tested against the median RAFE of other non-platform TDPs.
An option that is offered both through a platform and through a master trust (Hybrid platform TDP) will be tested twice, once as a platform TDP and once as a non-platform TDP with the worst result taken.


The Australian Fixed Income category would retain the Bloomberg Ausbond Composite 0+ Yr Index.
International credit will change to Bloomberg Global Aggregate Corporate Index (hedged AUD).

Australian and International Listed Infrastructure will change to FTSE Developed Core Infrastructure 50/50 100% Hedged to AUD Net Tax (Super) index.

The government will continue to explore and consult on further changes that improve the sophistication of the test to scrutinise underperformance across super products.

Read more about:


Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry



Planners will be in short supply, with only 376 in FY23–24. In my experience, of this number, only around 20% to 30% wi...

3 hours ago
Peter James

As usual there is no delineation in the article between risk specialist advisers and investment specialist advisers. Thi...

4 hours ago
Mark Harris

Is he serious, improvements from legislation change, all I see is more ASIC compliance and higher costs, this government...

5 hours ago

Insignia Financial has unveiled a new operating model and executive team, including a new head of advice, while three senior executives are set to depart the licensee....

1 week 5 days ago

The $280 billion Australian Retirement Trust is the first superannuation fund off the block to report its performance for the 2023-24 financial year....

3 weeks 1 day ago

Analysis by Chant West of the annual performance of growth superannuation funds has uncovered which ones see the best performance....

5 days ago


Fund name
Ardea Diversified Bond F
144.00 3 y p.a(%)
Hills International
63.39 3 y p.a(%)