Researchers to be liable for losses
A law firm has warned that ratings houses could be partially liable for money lost by investors in financial products they rate, following a landmark ruling in the Australian Federal Court.
Corrs Chambers Westgarth partner Rommel Harding-Farrenberg cautioned rating agencies, investment banks and investment managers to tread carefully when promoting financial products, after the Federal Court found investment research and ratings house Standard & Poor’s (S&P) engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct when it gave a top AAA rating to CPDOs - a highly leveraged financial product marketed as Rembrandt notes.
“This new and significant development follows a recent case where the court found rating agencies, investment managers and others can owe a duty of care to investors,” Harding-Farrenberg said.
“If a financial product has been inappropriately rated or marketed, the rating agency, originator and investment manager could be held accountable,” he added.
“On the one hand, this is a good result for investors. On the other, it should spark major changes in the due diligence and analysis process undertaken by rating agencies and other involved parties.”
The court found that S&P based the AAA rating solely on information provided by the creators of the product, ABN AMRO. Following large-scale investment, the value of Rembrandt notes plummeted, causing severe financial loss for investors.
As a result of the AAA rating, 13 councils in NSW invested $16 million in Rembrandt notes through an investment manager which had purchased $45 million worth of the notes itself.
The councils brought successful claims against S&P as well as ABN AMRO and the investment manager.
“This decision could have major global implications in relation to litigation pending against rating agencies in the United States and elsewhere,” Harding-Farrenberg said.
“The court will not impute responsibility simply because an investor has suffered losses.
“However, if there is evidence there was no reasonable basis for a rating, or where a rating analysis is not a result of an exercise of reasonable care, then rating agencies, developers and marketers of financial products may be vulnerable.”
Recommended for you
With an advice M&A deal taking around six months to enact, two experts have shared their tips on how buyers and sellers can avoid “deal fatigue” and prevent potential deals from collapsing.
Several financial advisers have been shortlisted in the ninth annual Women in Finance Awards 2025, to be held on 14 November.
Digital advice tools are on the rise, but licensees will need to ensure they still meet adviser obligations or potentially risk a class action if clients lose money from a rogue algorithm.
Shaw and Partners has merged with Sydney wealth manager Kennedy Partners Wealth, while Ord Minnett has hired a private wealth adviser from Morgan Stanley.
