FPA warns that automation doesn’t always equate to innovation
The Financial Planning Association (FPA) has warned the Government against allowing too much leeway with respect to the so-called regulatory sandbox, warning that just because a business is highly automated does necessarily make it innovative.
In a submission lodged with the Treasury this week, the FPA said that while it was prepared to support a framework in which the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) gives special weight to applications for relief for truly innovative business ideas, especially the testing of ideas, it was dubious about what represented innovation.
“To be clear, a heavily automated business is not necessarily innovative. Nor is yet another automated risk profiling tool or an [exchange traded fund] ETF investing tool,” the FPA submission said.
It said firms should be made to demonstrate they are genuinely innovative.
“Simply being heavily automated is not enough,” the submission said. “A close investigation is required to decide whether the firm is offering something genuinely novel and beneficial.”
The FPA said it would also be supportive of special consideration being given to the size of a firm, in circumstances where smaller firms might find it particularly difficult to enter the market.
“But, again, being small and heavily automated does not make a firm truly innovative (let alone innovative enough to outweigh the extra risk),” it said.
“In summary, a general exemption is inappropriate as there is a need to ascertain whether there is a net benefit,” it said. “This requires a close examination and a judgement. We should not let our excitement for the idea of innovation blind us to the risks.”
Recommended for you
With the highest number of candidates in a year sitting the latest financial advice exam, a surge of new entrants are expected in the coming weeks, according to Wealth Data.
AMP has launched a range of five diversified index managed portfolios on its North investment platform, targeting a younger client demographic.
An NSW adviser, who advised over 120 clients after falsifying her financial advice exam results, has been permanently banned by ASIC.
ASIC has released the results from the latest financial adviser exam, the first to be run since changes to its structure earlier this year.