Colonial Geared Investments' systems were flawed: former Storm Financial executive
The Commonwealth Bank of Australia’s Colonial Geared Investments arm did not have the human or technological resources to handle the share market meltdown and the subsequent sell-down of Storm Financial clients’ share portfolios, a parliamentary inquiry has heard.
A former executive of failed financial planning group Storm Financial has used his submission to the parliamentary inquiry to point to the inadequacies of the systems and staff of Colonial Geared Investments (CGI) in managing the margin loans and investments of Storm Financial clients.
Ron Jelich — who sold his financial planning business to Storm and later became a key executive within the group — believes software used by CGI, an investment arm of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), to monitor the margin loans of clients of Storm Financial was faulty.
Jelich said he believes the bank “did not have the human or technological resources to handle the meltdown in the frenetic period from early October to December [2008]”.
Jelich states that a “forensic examination of the CGI simulator” has shown that “some of the algorithms embedded in the CGI computer simulator software were flawed and thus gave false readings when under stress”.
“The huge volumes of transactions being conducted at the time made it impossible to track individual clients’ portfolios with any accuracy,” Jelich’s submission states.
“This made it impossible for investors and advisers to accurately monitor their fluctuating portfolios at this crucial time.”
Clients of Storm Financial had “no way of accurately tracking their portfolios and were given no forewarning of the bank’s decision to sell them out”, Jelich said. Neither were they given any opportunity to meet their commitments and to stay in the market if they so chose.
In his submission, Jelich states “CGI staff resources were grossly inadequate to discharge their duties in a ‘competent and efficient’ manner in their dealings with Storm Financial and its clients”.
Jelich’s submission said, “prior to the meltdown, the monitoring of all [CGI] margin loans with Storm [were] handled by one staff member sitting at a computer screen in Sydney, to the best of my knowledge”.
According to Jelich, a report relating to flaws in the CGI simulator is the subject of a separate submission to the parliamentary inquiry.
Jelich also states in his submission that in March 2008, “a system was developed by the CBA and linked to Storm’s computer systems to allow the bank to conduct remote valuations of all assets of joint clients of Storm and the CBA”.
“If the valuations showed that the clients had sufficient equity, a recommendation would be made by Storm for them to borrow more money,” Jelich said.
Recommended for you
With the final tally for FY25 now confirmed, how many advisers left during the financial year and how does it compare to the previous year?
HUB24 has appointed Matt Willis from Vanguard as an executive general manager of platform growth to strengthen the platform’s relationships with industry stakeholders.
Investment manager Drummond Capital Partners has announced a raft of adviser-focused updates, including a practice growth division, relaunched manager research capabilities, and a passive model portfolio suite.
When it comes to M&A activity, the share of financial buyers such as private equity firms in Australia fell from 67 per cent to 12 per cent in the last financial year.
