Peer group comparisons imperfect tool

investment-trends/director/

8 September 2008
| By Internal |

The problem with peer group comparisons is that they often don’t compare like with like, according to Russell Investments director of fiduciary research Scott Donald.

“It is about how reliable are the organisations you are including in the comparisons,” he told a Russell investment conference in Melbourne.

“There are differences in the way fund performance is calculated, for example, so it is hard to see what the objectives of a comparison will be.”

Donald said there were also issues about how the comparison data had been compiled historically as it may include organisations that had ceased operating.

“Survivorship bias is really important as it affects the performance of today’s participants,” he said.

“Funds disappear because they underperform so if they are still included in the data, the surviving funds are biased upwards.”

Another danger is using ‘median’ managers as the basis for the comparison.

Donald said what is defined as a ‘median’ manager may in fact not exist in a particular data set, so those doing the comparison end up creating a middle point that could be inaccurate.

“This ends up with the comparison creating a median that is not replicable elsewhere,” he said.

“Most investment comparisons are a mismatch between what you want to compare and the actual investment.”

Another problem is the observation delay as research can be up to six months out of date.

“So the comparisons are based on investment trends of six months ago and the truth about what has happened only comes out later,” Donald said.

The use of peer comparisons also raises some questions.

He said if you ignore this form of peer comparison in decision-making, you risk regrets.

“If you do include this comparison, define your peer group carefully and research the input data,” he said.

“You have also got to perform the same analysis each time you decide to undertake peer comparisons.”

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

The succession dilemma is more than just a matter of commitments.This isn’t simply about younger vs. older advisers. It’...

1 week 4 days ago

Significant ethical issues there. If a relationship is in the process of breaking down then both parties are likely to b...

1 month ago

It's not licensees not putting them on, it's small businesses (that are licensed) that cannot afford to put them on. The...

1 month 1 week ago

AMP has settled on two court proceedings: one class action which affected superannuation members and a second regarding insurer policies. ...

3 days 18 hours ago

ASIC has released the results of the latest adviser exam, with August’s pass mark improving on the sitting from a year ago. ...

1 week 6 days ago

The inquiry into the collapse of Dixon Advisory and broader wealth management companies by the Senate economics references committee will not be re-adopted. ...

2 weeks 6 days ago

TOP PERFORMING FUNDS

ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND
Powered by MOMENTUM MEDIA
moneymanagement logo