Did TAL incentivise managers to deny claims?

TAL has today faced rigorous questioning by the Royal Commission into the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry on whether case managers and senior staff were incentivised to deny claims as quickly as possible.

Senior Counsel assisting the Commission, Rowena Orr QC, introduced evidence suggesting that a key performance indicator (KPI) for senior case managers was declining claims, contending that this was “a driver for the poor conduct” observed in this round of hearings.

TAL general manager, Loraine Van Eeden, said that she could not comment on that suggestion, “as I do not see any rewarding or benefits paid to people based on this [declining claims]”. She was unable to confirm any of the KPIs for case managers at the time of the conduct the evidence referenced.

Related News:

Documents tabled describing the responsibilities of case managers referenced bringing claims to an end as quickly as possible however, with Commissioner Kenneth Hayne QC suggesting that the case manager’s behaviour in the case study introduced by Orr was in aid of, and for which they would likely be rewarded.

While Van Eeden agreed that that was why the manager acted how they did, she said she couldn’t comment on whether it was rewarded.

“The fact that you can’t comment on it leads me to infer that you, being the witness put forward by TAL, that is their expectation when I see in the 2015 documents that that is the way in which people were awarded after these events,” Hayne said.

Orr validly questioned whether Van Eeden, whom TAL had “assured the Commission was the best person” to speak on the issues being addressed, could in fact provide answers to the inquiry.

Related Content

OnePath consumers’ top pick for insurance

OnePath has won the over Association of Financial Advisers (AFA) and the Beddoes Institute 2018 Consumer Choice Award, with ClearView coming in second...Read more

Do insurers pay to influence advice?

Financial Services Council (FSC) chief executive, Sally Loane, has faced questioning at the Royal Commission on the relationship between the life insu...Read more

Industry fund planners received conflicted remuneration

Industry superannuation fund body, Industry Fund Services (IFS) has acknowledged some of its financial advisers have been in receipt of conflicted rem...Read more



Add new comment