Fund managers feeling pressure from super internalisation
A quarter of fund managers surveyed by Frontier have named the move towards internalisation by super funds as the biggest challenge to their business.
In a 10-year review of the firm’s annual fund manager survey, it questioned fund managers on the challenges facing them ahead.
Two factors have emerged as significant issues: internalisation of investment management by clients (25 per cent) and consolidation of super funds (29 per cent).
However, fears about consolidation are down from 49 per cent last year, indicating managers believe the volume of large mergers is decreasing.
Concerns of fund managers
| Fund management concern | Percentage |
| Consolidation of super funds | 29% |
| Internalisation of investment management by clients | 25% |
| Pressure from clients for fees to contract and impact on revenue | 19% |
| Regulation | 10% |
| Other | 8% |
| Markets | 7% |
| Ability to attract and retain talent | 2% |
Source: Frontier, October 2023
According to the study: “Over time the challenge of internalisation has been growing in terms of its prominence in responses. This year it has almost climbed into the top ranking with 25 per cent choosing it as their most significant issue.
"It is obvious that, while consolidation continues to loom as a threat for managers (and for consultants as well), the majority of that appears to be behind us and the challenge of larger internal teams now looms as the more immediate threat for managers looking to cling on to mandates.
“There is substantially more money needing to be invested in the superannuation system now, but the concentration of that money across an ever-reducing number of funds is clearly causing concern for fund managers with respect to their operations.”
The percentage of fund managers who believe they should be remunerated on performance and that external fund managers provide a depth of research and developments that cannot be matched by internal teams is unchanged from 10 years ago at 33 per cent and 45 per cent.
However, this contradicts 39 per cent who believe internal teams are best placed to research and advise on investments for their fund.
When it comes to fees, large super funds (those over $50 billion) are nominated as the most fee-sensitive investors followed by smaller super funds and insurers. Fund managers also feel super funds focus too much on minimising costs and not enough on maximising returns.
Some 83 per cent of fund managers feel returns are being compromised in a bid to keep costs low.
"In our most recent survey, 83 per cent of managers feel returns are being compromised in the quest to contain costs. This score has been steadily climbing each year since 2015 (70 per cent).”
Despite challenges, 93 per cent of fund managers are predicting business growth between now and 2028, although Frontier noted the figure has been as high as 97 per cent in 2016.
AUTHOR
Laura Dew
Recommended for you
Insignia Financial has reported net inflows of $448 million into its asset management division in the latest quarter, as well as popularity from advisers for its MLC managed accounts.
With ASIC questioning the dominance of research houses when it comes to retail usage of private market funds, a research house has shared how its ranking process sits alongside ASIC’s priorities.
Two Australian active fund managers have been singled out by Morningstar for their ability to achieve consistent performance and share price growth in the past 12 months.
Pinnacle Investment Management has expanded its private market coverage, forging a strategic partnership with a private markets manager via a 13 per cent stake acquisition.
