ESG scoring creating increased investment risk for investors

18 December 2020
| By Laura Dew |
image
image image
expand image

While a score-based approach to environmental, social and governance (ESG) serves the interest of ratings providers, it is not always a useful guide for investors and could lead to increased risk. 

According to Scientific Beta, in its paper ‘Scoring against ESG? Avoiding the pitfalls of ESG scores in portfolio construction’, scoring was not found to guide investors on ESG investing. There were numerous different types of scoring, definitions and data available which created inconsistences and led to subjective assessments being made. 

This echoed previous criticism by the OECD who said ESG scores should not be viewed as a meaningful indicator of a strategy’s ESG goals. 

It was particularly the case when it came to the environmental and the fight against climate change and the rise in greenwashing. 

There were also concerns linked to averaging ESG scores across a portfolio and using such an average as a goal or constraint in portfolio construction as portfolio optimisation based on averages could magnify the estimation of individual ESG scores. 

The organisation said: “Average ESG scores provide useful insights only if one assumes that scores very accurately proxy for ESG risks and furthermore that these risks are linear. None of these assumptions are substantiated by academic studies, or even by intuition or casual observation. Ultimately, the use of these global scores leads to increased investment risks”. 

AUTHOR

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

So we are now underwriting criminal scams?...

5 months ago

Glad to see the back of you Steve. You made financial more expensive, not more affordable as you claim, and presided ...

5 months 1 week ago

Completely agree Peter. The definition of 'significant change is circumstances relevant to the scope of the advice' is s...

7 months 1 week ago

The FSCP has issued a written direction to an adviser who charged clients “extraordinary fees” for inappropriate and conflicted advice, as well as encouraged them to swit...

1 week 6 days ago

ASIC has cancelled the AFSL of an advice firm associated with Shield and First Guardian collapses, and permanently banned its responsible manager. ...

3 weeks 2 days ago

ASIC has confirmed the industry funding levy for the 2024–25 financial year, and how much licensees can expect to pay....

3 days 12 hours ago

TOP PERFORMING FUNDS

ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND
Fund name
3y(%)pa
2
DomaCom DFS Mortgage
95.46 3 y p.a(%)
5