ESG funds may be ESG only at one point in time
If a portfolio scores highly on environmental, social, governance (ESG) metrics it does not necessarily mean it is an ESG portfolio, rather that it was an ESG fund at that point in time, according to Evergreen Consultants.
Evergreen founder and chief executive, Angela Ashton, said there were a lot of ESG or responsible investment (RI) branded funds which were not. She said if investors were checking the PE of a fund and it was low, it did not mean it was a value fund but that it was just a value fund at that point in time.
Ashton said Evergreen launched its Evergreen Responsible Investing Grade Index (ERIG Index) on 26 March which was an assessment of RI metrics across funds that branded themselves as RI, ESG, or ethical.
The index used a top-down approach based on the Responsible Investments Association Australasia (RIAA) and UN Principles of Responsible Investment metrics and resources to show investors where funds sat on their RI journey compared to the average.
“We think about how the fund manager includes RI in their process. We used the RIAA and UNPRI resources and Australianised it and came up with a questionnaire that we presented to over 200 funds,” she said.
“A portfolio with a certain sustainability score does not necessarily mean the manager is an RI manager. It is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition to prove the style.
“We look at what the manager does and compare this to others in the marketplace. The bottom-up analysis of the manager’s portfolio can play a part, but it is not the complete analysis in our view.”
Recommended for you
Insignia Financial has reported net inflows of $448 million into its asset management division in the latest quarter, as well as popularity from advisers for its MLC managed accounts.
Two Australian active fund managers have been singled out by Morningstar for their ability to achieve consistent performance and share price growth in the past 12 months.
Pinnacle Investment Management has expanded its private market coverage, forging a strategic partnership with a private markets manager via a 13 per cent stake acquisition.
Active fund managers without a strong distribution platform will be “left behind”, believes Magellan, as it pivots its business away from being a traditional asset manager.
