Australia’s largest manager blasé on responsible investment

Macquarie Asset Management rating responsible investing asset managers ShareAction climate change biodiversity UNPRI united nations' principles of responsible investment social crisis ecological crises robecco bnp paribas asset management Legal and general investment management APG asset management Aviva Investors passive managers E fund management metlife investment management fidelity investments credit suisse asset management JP Morgan Asset Management blackrock vanguard State Street Global Advisors ssga Capital Group fixed income fixed income managers

13 March 2020
| By Jassmyn |
expand image

Macquarie Asset Management has been given a low rating of ‘D’ for its approach to responsible investment compared to its global large asset management counterparts. 

The ranking by ShareAction, a non-profit organisation that promotes responsible investment, looked at the world’s 75 largest asset managers across four metrics – responsible investment governance, climate change, human rights, and biodiversity.  

Macquarie was the only Australian representative and was ranked 55th. The report noted that all managers within Asia Pacific generally performed poorly, with Japan leading the pack. 

The ‘D’ rating was described as “business as usual” with “little evidence to suggest adequate management of material responsible investment risks and opportunities”. 

All assessed managers were members of the United Nation’s Principles of Responsible Investment (UNPRI). 

“The scale and urgency of current ecological and social crises demands far more than a ‘business-as-usual’ approach from asset managers, who are encouraged to use this ranking and report findings to benchmark their individual performance and drive improvements where needed.” 

“…While many PRI members show signs of leadership in responsible investment, many of the assessed managers also appear to use the initiative as a tick box exercise. Clients ought not to take membership of the PRI as a proxy for a good responsible investment approach and should ask managers questions about their policies and practices.” 

Robeco topped the rankings, followed by BNP Paribas Asset Management, Legal and General Investment Management, APG Asset Management, and Aviva Investors. The top five managers all received an ‘A’ rating. 

Legal and General was the only passive manager to crack the top five which the report said demonstrated that passive investors could have a leading approach to responsible investment. 

The ‘A’ rating was not the highest rating but was described the managers as “leaders” that had “strong management of risks and opportunities as well as impacts across multiple responsible investment themes”. 

No manager received a ‘AAA’ rating that was described as a “gold standard” where “leading practice performance in managing risks and opportunities as well as impacts across all assessed responsible investment themes”. An ‘AA’ rating was also not given to any manager. 

The bottom ranked managers were E Fund Management, MetLife Investment Management, Fidelity Investments, Credit Suisse Asset Management, and J.P. Morgan Asset Management. All managers received an ‘E’ rating.  

‘E’ ranked managers were described as “laggards” as “evidence suggests poor management of material responsible investment risks and opportunities”. 

The six largest managers by assets under management (AUM), with a combined US$20 trillion ($30.98 trillion) all received either a ‘D’ or ‘E’ rating.  

These managers were BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street Global Advisors, Fidelity Investments, Capital Group, and J.P. Morgan Asset Management.  

“…despite their size, they all performed poorly on the factors we see as fundamental to robust responsible investment practices,” the report said. 

Fixed income focused managers had rankings between ‘BBB’ and ‘E’ but none in the AAA to A categories.  

“While some asset managers demonstrate leadership in particular areas, none are performing strongly across each of the topics included in our methodology,” ShareAction said. 

Read more about:


Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry




4 days 10 hours ago
Chris Cornish

What a sticth-up. Looks like Labor Senator Jess Walsh follows Stephen Jones who follows what the industry super funds ...

4 days 7 hours ago
Peter Swan

This report is a blatant display of far-left factional partisanship, treating superannuation funds as state property and...

4 days 8 hours ago

ASIC has cancelled the AFS licence of a Sydney wealth firm, the fifth Sydney firm to see a cancellation since the start of the year....

2 weeks 5 days ago

More than 20 winners from the funds management industry have been crowned at this year’s awards....

1 week 5 days ago

ASIC has obtained interim orders from the Federal Court to freeze the assets of a registered managed fund and prevent its former director from leaving Australia. ...

6 days 7 hours ago