Morningstar case moves to next step
Thelegal battle between Graham Rich andMorningstar Australiaand Morningstar Incorporated lurched ahead last week after the Federal Court gave directions that the two separate legal actions underway by Rich be combined into a single NSW Supreme Court case.
Rich’s departure from Morningstar two years ago, after holding the post of managing director, sparked the two legal actions, with one initiated through the Industrial Relations Commission (IRC) for unfair dismissal seeking $25 million in compensation.
The second case is with the NSW Supreme Court and concerns breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty and oppression, but will now become the only case to be pursued after the Federal Court ruled cross-vesting had occurred between the cases and they should be treated as a single action.
The move also resulted in the case not being elevated to the Federal Court, which had been raised as part of the proceedings in deciding the jurisdiction under which the cases would be heard.
Morningstar had also requested a claim on security for the costs to fully pursue the case, stating it would cost $3.5 million, and had questioned whether similar funds were available to Rich.
This had been countered, with Rich stating his holdings in Morningstar, through his own company Fiduciary, were sufficient to act as security and cover the amount needed to complete the legal action.
AUTHOR
Jason Spits
Recommended for you
The new financial year has got off to a strong start in adviser gains, helped by new entrants, after heavy losses sustained in June.
Michael McCorry, chief investment officer at BlackRock Australia, has detailed how investors are reconsidering their 60/40 portfolios as macro uncertainty highlight the benefits of liquid alternatives.
Having reset its market focus to high-net-worth advisers, Praemium’s administration solution has been selected by Bell Potter in a deal that increases the platform's funds under administration by $6 billion.
High transition rates from financial advisers have helped Netwealth’s funds under administration rise by $3.7 billion in the fourth quarter of FY25.
