Consumers unwilling to face reality of failing investments
Members of failing investment schemes are unwilling to consider they might be in trouble if they are still seeing positive returns, making it hard for the regulator to crack down early.
Appearing before the Senate Economics Committee, Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), senior executive leader for insurers, Rhys Bollen, was asked why ASIC had not investigated the failing Sterling Income Trust earlier. Bollen said it was difficult to convince people of problems at an early stage if they were still seeing positives from their investment.
“If you ask the investor ‘are you happy?’, and they have the benefit of a roof over their head and they’re living in the residence then they have no reason not to be happy,” Bollen said.
“It’s like if you went to the passengers on the Titanic in the main dining room and asked if they were having a pleasant journey. They would say ‘yes’ but the fact of the matter is there still aren’t enough lifeboats and it is a tragedy waiting to happen.”
ASIC chair, Joe Longo, added people had viewed the investment as attractive which made it difficult for them to accept that it was not as good as they expected. Earlier in the day, Ben Marshan, head of policy, strategy and innovation at the Financial Planning Association of Australia, had told the committee investors viewed the scheme as “their dreams were coming true”.
Longo said: “If things are going smoothly at that moment, it’s very hard for someone to disrupt that decision. If things are going well, they don’t want someone like me or ASIC coming along and telling them they have made the wrong decision and they shouldn’t be enjoying those returns.
“There’s a real ambivalence on the part of investors to face a reality that they didn’t expect to have to face.
“With the benefit of hindsight and knowing what happened afterwards, we could have moved more quickly.”
AUTHOR
Laura Dew
Recommended for you
The Australian Financial Complaints Authority has reported an 18 per cent increase in investment and advice complaints received in the financial year 2025, rebounding from the previous year’s 26 per cent dip.
As reports flow in of investors lining up to buy gold at Sydney’s ABC Bullion store this week, two financial advisers have cautioned against succumbing to the hype as gold prices hit shaky ground.
After three weeks of struggling gains, this week has marked a return to strong growth for adviser numbers, in addition to three new licensees commencing.
ASIC has banned a Melbourne-based financial adviser who gave inappropriate advice to his clients including false and misleading Statements of Advice.
