Ending grandfathered trails will enrich banks, not clients
The Productivity Commission (PC) and other elements calling for an immediate end to grandfathered trailing commissions need to understand that banks and other product manufacturers may be the ultimate beneficiaries rather than financial planning clients, according to Association of Financial Advisers (AFA) chief executive, Phil Kewin.
Kewin also pointed to the reality that a market had been created for books of trails which could see some planners facing substantial commercial losses in the event that a future Government moved in line with the PC’s recommendations to immediately end the grandfathered arrangements.
He said the AFA was firmly opposed to fee for no service in the context of grandfathered trailing commissions and firmly believed that financial advisers who acquired books of trails should be actually servicing those clients.
However, he said that advisers who had purchased books of trails, sometimes financed by the financial institutions for which they worked, had done so in good faith and consistent with the law as it existed at the time.
Kewin said that it was in these circumstances that there should be no unilateral decision by Government to end grandfathered trails but, rather, a fully informed debate.
“The writing may be on the wall for grandfathered commissions, but there is a need for discussion and debate about the consequences not only for advisers but for clients,” he said.
“The reality is that ending the trails will not necessarily result in the money going to clients, it may very likely end up being taken by the financial institutions,” Kewin said.
Recommended for you
As the first quarter of 2024 comes to a close, Money Management looks back on the corporate regulator’s bans and AFSL cancellations in the financial advice sector.
Insignia Financial is holding ‘relatively steady’ onto its rank as Australia’s second-largest financial advice licensee after the Godfrey Pembroke exit but Count is hot on its heels.
Liberal senator Slade Brockman has said the government needs to have a “cold hard look” at the level of regulation in the financial advice space and the costs of running a business.
FAAA chief executive, Sarah Abood, has warned changes in the first tranche of the QAR legislation around advice fees documentation could create more work for advisers rather than less.