“Returns gap” the biggest failure in investment industry
The investor returns gap means that even for asset managers skilled enough to produce alpha, chances are their clients won’t be able to fully capture it in their own portfolios because of the clients’ investment timing decisions, according to Research Affiliates.
It is for this reason that the research house calls the investor returns gap “the biggest failure in the investment industry”.
In a new white paper, John West and Jason Hsu of Research Affiliates looked at how the gap between the returns realised by the investor and the returns earned by the strategy or fund the investor owns was overshadowed by the spotlight focused on alpha.
Smart beta was no exception, they said.
So, West and Hsu proposed two ways to reframe the client performance review that they believed would result in better long-term outcomes.
“The negative gap between investor returns and fund returns is the biggest failure in investment management. Alpha is only a sideshow,” they said.
“If we extrapolate the investor returns gap to smart beta strategies, poor client timing will completely negate the potential for positive excess returns.
“The client service model for smart beta strategies needs to be radically different from other types of strategies to produce better investor outcomes.”
West and Hu said investment professionals must also strive to help clients understand how to stay the course by understanding the styles in which they choose to invest.
“A new mindset is called on for both professionals in how they frame their advice and for clients as they learn to adjust their expectations and adopt longer horizons for assessing performance,” they said.
West and Hu said that sadly, many high-tracking-error smart beta strategies may actually exacerbate the investor returns gap, especially if “noisy” short-term performance is sold to trend-chasing clients.
“The investor returns gap of nearly 2 per cent will wipe out the majority of smart beta strategies’ long-term returns. But we’re optimistic. We believe this cycle can be broken. Robust, academic-quality research and efficiently designed products are important, but no longer enough,” they said.
“To avoid the biggest failure in investment management, we must embrace a new
Recommended for you
Australian and New Zealand sustainable funds saw outflows of more than $1.2 billion in the second quarter of 2024, according to Morningstar, with active strategies accounting for the majority.
Maple-Brown Abbott has finalised an agreement to be acquired by a rival fund manager to create a firm with $18.6 billion in assets under management, just two months after its former CEO exited to lead Magellan.
Following a strategic review, Platinum has announced it will merge its two listed investment companies with two of its quoted managed hedge funds.
With potential US interest rate cuts on the horizon, Income Asset Management believes now is an ideal time to be investing into the corporate bond market.
