Why digital advice won’t solve the accessibility gap

super investments Paul Moran digital advice

25 November 2022
| By Jasmine Siljic |
image
image
expand image

Transitioning to digital advice is not the answer to the advice affordability and accessibility dilemma, according to Dr Paul Moran.

The founder of iFactFind and principal of Moran Partners Financial Planning presented his doctoral research findings at the FPA Professional Congress in Sydney. 

His quantitative study explored the connection between investor beliefs and financial behaviour, and was completed by 280 respondents. 

Despite other professionals at the event who expected to see a beneficial rise in digital advice due to the finite size of the financial advice industry, Moran urged otherwise.

“If clients don’t know what they don’t know, and digital advice platforms only ask questions designed to obtain a predetermined outcome, otherwise called an algorithm, it is questionable how much they can really help,” he said.

Moran added: “Problematically, people typically use digital experiences to obtain pleasurable outcomes, like buying clothes and concert tickets, but not for things like life insurance and topping up super, which doesn’t help solve the advice access issues.”

His research additionally reinforced the importance of professional advice due to a trend in investors who demonstrated problematic asset allocation behaviour. 

This was largely underpinned by unreliable research on past performance which had misled investors.

“The most important factor in investment decision-making is people’s perception of past performance and most of the time that perception is poor or just plain wrong,” he said.

“When asked to choose the best past performer out of superannuation, Australian shares and residential real estate, more than 60% of people got it wrong yet they indicated that past performance was a significant factor in their asset allocation decisions.” 

The way that questions were constructed significantly affected how investors selected their investment preferences.

When asked to choose their favoured asset class based on past performance, 38% of investors selected Australian shares, 33% selected real estate and 26% chose super.

Contrastingly, the results differed when asked the same question but based upon participants’ forecasts for future performance. Nearly 50% of respondents selected shares, 18% chose real estate and 33% selected super. 

Moran said: “People can give very different responses to the same question, depending on how the question is framed.”

“The research reinforces the importance of having an experienced adviser to help guide clients to make smart decisions,” he concluded.

 

Read more about:

AUTHOR

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Recommended for you

sub-bgsidebar subscription

Never miss the latest news and developments in wealth management industry

MARKET INSIGHTS

Peter Johnson

As others have said - plenty of excuses for further falls. How about decades of being continually beaten down by the...

2 hours 55 minutes ago
Duke Nukem

Finally someone with the guts to ask the hard questions of the corrupt body that governs us. Good on you Angry, ASIC mak...

4 hours ago
Alex

Planners will be in short supply, with only 376 in FY23–24. In my experience, of this number, only around 20% to 30% wi...

1 day ago

Insignia Financial has unveiled a new operating model and executive team, including a new head of advice, while three senior executives are set to depart the licensee....

1 week 6 days ago

ASIC has secured travel restraint orders against a financial adviser while he is the subject of an investigation into alleged financial misconduct....

1 day 20 hours ago

The $280 billion Australian Retirement Trust is the first superannuation fund off the block to report its performance for the 2023-24 financial year....

3 weeks 2 days ago

TOP PERFORMING FUNDS

ACS FIXED INT - AUSTRALIA/GLOBAL BOND
Fund name
3y(%)pa
1
Ardea Diversified Bond F
144.00 3 y p.a(%)
3
Hills International
63.39 3 y p.a(%)